A police officer arrested you for robbery in Indiana. Now you face a serious criminal charge that could put you behind bars. You need a skilled robbery defense attorney to fight for your rights and a favorable case outcome. The proven Indiana criminal defense attorneys at Gemma & Karimi have acquired an outstanding record of robbery and theft charge reductions, dismissals, and not guilty verdicts. Contact our Indianapolis robbery defense attorney immediately for a free consultation at (317) 602-5970.
Robbery Laws in Indiana
Indiana Code 35-42-5-1 defines robbery as taking property from another person by threat of force or putting the person in fear. Key elements of a robbery crime in Indiana are:
- The offender, knowingly and intentionally, took the property from another person.
- The offender used force or fear to take the property, threat of force, or induced fear in the crime victim.
- The offender acted knowingly or intentionally.
Robbery is a felony in Indiana, and the severity depends on these factors:
- Level 5 felony: The robbery caused no serious bodily injury, and no weapon was involved.
- Level 3 felony: It was an armed robbery committed with a weapon or caused bodily injury to another person.
- Level 2 felony: The robbery caused serious bodily injury to another person.
Armed robbery and aggravated robbery are related offenses that may trigger additional criminal charges. If no fear or force was involved in the incident, you could be charged with a lesser theft crime.

Facing Robbery charges in Indianapolis?
Call our Indianapolis Robbery Defense attorney at (317) 602-5970 or fill out our online contact form today to schedule a free consultation!
Defending Against Armed Robbery Charges
The state prosecutor must prove your guilt for robbery beyond a reasonable doubt, and many strong defenses exist for this charge:
Mistaken identity: You may have an alibi that proves you could not have committed robbery.
No intent: Robbery requires the state to prove that you knowingly or intentionally took the person’s property. The charge could be dismissed or reduced if your attorney shows no intent.
Insufficient evidence: Concrete proof, such as witness statements, surveillance video footage, fingerprints, etc., must tie you to the robbery.
Choosing the Right Robbery Defense Lawyer
A robbery conviction can put you in jail for years, so you must select a skilled criminal defense attorney with a proven record. Our seasoned Indianapolis robbery defense attorney can defend your rights and fight tenaciously for the best case outcome.
Our skilled criminal defense attorneys have obtained hundreds of case dismissals, acquittals, and charge reductions in property crime cases.
Taking Action Against Indianapolis Robbery Charges
Arrested for an Indianapolis robbery charge? The state prosecutor possesses extensive monetary and personal resources to convict you of a felony. Our proven criminal defense attorneys will:
- Provide a free case evaluation: We will review your charge details, including what happened, evidence, police report, and witness statements, to pinpoint weaknesses in the state’s case.
- Build a robust defense: Depending on the situation, our lawyers may argue that you did not commit felony robbery because of no intent.
- Deal with local courts: Our attorneys are Indianapolis natives and know the local courts, jduges, and prosecutors. This knowledge helps obtain a favorable outcome.
- Plea bargaining: We may negotiate with the prosecutor to lessen the charge or sentence.
- Trial representation: If the case goes to trial, we will represent you and argue on your behalf.
Frequently Asked Questions
Exercise your right to remain silent immediately. Do not speak to police or investigators without an attorney present. Contact a criminal defense lawyer as soon as possible to protect your rights and begin building your defense.
The key difference is the use of force or fear. Theft (larceny) is taking property without consent, while robbery is taking property from a person using violence, intimidation, or threats of harm.
Armed robbery involves the use of a deadly weapon (like a gun or knife) or the pretense of having one during the crime. This is considered an aggravating factor and carries significantly harsher penalties than simple robbery.
Penalties vary by state and severity but often include lengthy prison sentences, heavy fines, restitution to victims, and a permanent felony record. Armed robbery can result in mandatory minimum prison terms of 10-20 years or more.
Yes. A skilled defense attorney can negotiate with prosecutors to reduce charges to lesser offenses like theft, assault, or trespassing, especially if the evidence of force or weapon use is weak.
Common defenses include mistaken identity, lack of intent to steal, ownership of the property (claim of right), or lack of force/fear used during the incident. Alibis and challenging witness credibility are also standard strategies.
“Beating” a charge often involves suppressing illegally obtained evidence, exposing inconsistencies in witness statements, or proving you were not present at the scene (alibi). Your lawyer will investigate every detail to create reasonable doubt.
The prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you took property from another person against their will using force or threats. Evidence often includes surveillance video, witness testimony, DNA, or possession of stolen items.
We analyze police reports for procedural errors, interview witnesses, consult forensic experts, and negotiate with prosecutors. Our goal is to get charges dismissed, reduced, or to win an acquittal at trial.
After arrest, you will be booked and held for an arraignment where charges are read and bail is set. It is critical to have counsel present at the arraignment to argue for lower bail or release on your own recognizance.
Yes. Strong-arm robbery (often called mugging) involves using physical force without a weapon. It is typically charged as a felony and carries serious prison time, though less than armed robbery.
Sometimes. Voluntary intoxication is generally not a complete defense, but it can be used to argue that the defendant could not form the specific “intent” required to commit a robbery, potentially lowering the charge to a lesser crime.
Eyewitness testimony is often unreliable due to stress, poor lighting, or cross-racial identification issues. We aggressively cross-examine witnesses and may use experts to demonstrate how memory can be flawed.
In many jurisdictions, using a fake or toy gun still qualifies as armed robbery if the victim reasonably believed it was real and felt threatened. However, it can sometimes be a mitigating factor during sentencing.
We provide aggressive, experience-driven representation. We understand the high stakes of violent crime accusations and work tirelessly to challenge the prosecution’s case, protect your freedom, and secure the best possible outcome.
Contacting a Robbery Defense Lawyer in Indiana
Were you recently charged with robbery? It’s terrifying to know you could go to jail and be stuck with a criminal record. Always rely on a skilled, aggressive robbery defense attorney to defend you.
Gemma & Karimi have over 25 years of combined criminal plea bargain and trial experience defending people charged with robbery and theft. Our criminal defense lawyers are ex-prosecutors and understand both sides of the law, which works to your advantage. Contact us at (317) 602-5970 for an immediate, free consultation about your robbery case.
Contact Our Firm
Interested in our services? Fill out some info and we will be in touch shortly. We can’t wait to hear from you!