In Indiana, a murder charge is one of the most serious criminal accusations you can face. Murder in this state is defined as knowingly or intentionally killing another human being or killing someone while committing or attempting to commit certain felonies.. This includes crimes like arson, burglary, child molesting, kidnapping, rape, robbery, carjacking, or criminal gang activity.
You should immediately retain a highly skilled criminal defense lawyer at Gemma & Karimi to defend you against this dire charge. You face decades in prison, fines, and a criminal record that will affect your life forever. Retain skilled criminal defense attorneys now to protect your rights and future.
Understanding Murder Charges in Indiana
In Indiana, murder is most often the intentional killing of another person. A person murders if they knowingly or intentionally cause the death of another person. “Knowingly” means the individual is aware their actions will likely result in death, while “intentionally” implies a deliberate purpose to kill.
Another potential charge in Indiana is felony murder. This is killing that occurs during the commission or attempted commission of specific felonies, such as arson, burglary, child molesting, kidnapping, rape, robbery, or carjacking. It can also be charged as murder, even if the death was not intended. For example, if someone dies during a bank robbery, all participants in the felony can potentially face murder charges.
The penalties for murder in Indiana can be severe, including 45 to 65 years in state prison and up to $10,000 in fines. You can also receive a life sentence without parole if there are aggravating circumstances, such as several victims.
The death penalty is also a possibility, with at least one aggravating circumstance must exist beyond a reasonable doubt. Aggravating circumstances for the death penalty include if the murder was committed during a robbery, kidnapping, or burglary. Or the murder victim was a law enforcement officer or judge, or the murder was committed in a particularly heinous or cruel manner.
Keep in mind that if you are convicted of murder, judges have limited discretion within the 45-65-year range for a standard murder conviction. Still, they may consider mitigating factors. For example, the judge could impose a lesser sentence if you have no previous criminal history or mental health problems.
On the other hand, aggravating factors, such as a particularly heinous act or prior convictions, could push the sentence toward the maximum or beyond to life without parole.
Indiana does not offer probation or suspended sentences as standalone alternatives for a murder conviction due to the severity of the crime. However, credit time for good behavior or educational achievements can reduce the actual time served within the 45-65-year range, though this does not apply to life without parole or death penalty cases.
Facing criminal charges in Indianapolis?
Call our Indiana Criminal Defense attorney at (317) 676-4747 or fill out our online contact form today to schedule a free consultation!
Related Murder Offenses
You can still face severe criminal penalties even if you are not charged with murder in Indiana. These are related offenses that can still lead to years in prison, if convicted:
- Voluntary manslaughter: An intentional killing committed in the “sudden heat” of passion due to provocation. This carries a lesser penalty, typically 10 to 30 years.
- Involuntary manslaughter: An unintentional killing resulting from reckless behavior or during a misdemeanor, with penalties of 2 to 12 years.
- Reckless homicide: A death caused by reckless actions but not intentional, punishable by 1 to 6 years.
Additional Consequences for an Indiana Murder Conviction
You do not merely face decades in prison and fines with an Indiana murder conviction. You will be stuck with a permanent criminal record that will probably follow you for life. Additional consequences of a felony criminal conviction are many, including:
Loss of Voting Rights
In Indiana, a felony conviction like murder results in the temporary loss of voting rights. You cannot vote while incarcerated, but these rights are automatically restored upon release from prison, including parole or probation, as long as you’re no longer confined.
Firearm Restrictions
A murder conviction permanently prohibits you from owning, possessing, or using firearms under both Indiana state law and federal law. This restriction is lifelong and non-negotiable due to the violent nature of the offense.
Employment Problems
Finding work after a murder conviction is extremely difficult. Many employers conduct background checks and may legally refuse to hire individuals with felony convictions, especially for violent crimes. Jobs requiring licenses, such as teaching and healthcare, are typically inaccessible, as licensing boards often deny or revoke credentials based on such convictions.
Professional Licensing
Indiana regulates numerous professions, and a murder conviction almost certainly disqualifies you from obtaining or retaining licenses in fields like medicine, education, or real estate. The state’s licensing authorities consider the nature of the crime, and a violent felony like murder is a near-automatic bar.
Housing Problems
Public housing authorities and private landlords can deny tenancy to individuals with felony convictions, particularly violent ones. A murder conviction may lead to exclusion from government-assisted housing programs and make securing a lease nearly impossible due to background checks.
Social and Familial Impact
Beyond legal restrictions, a murder conviction carries significant stigma, often leading to strained or severed personal relationships. If you have children, custody or visitation rights could be heavily restricted or terminated, as courts prioritize the child’s safety and well-being.
Immigration Consequences
If you’re not a U.S. citizen, a murder conviction in Indiana will almost certainly lead to deportation proceedings after serving your sentence, as it qualifies as an “aggravated felony” under federal immigration law.
Financial and Educational Limits
A murder conviction can disqualify you from certain federal and state benefits, including student loans or grants, making higher education or vocational training harder to pursue post-release.
Clearly, the long-term consequences of a murder conviction are severe. Always retain a strong criminal defense law firm to build a strong criminal defense. Our Indiana criminal defense lawyer will ensure that you have the best chance to have the case dismissed or charge reduced.
What to Do if You’re Arrested for Murder
If you are arrested for murder in Indiana, it is critical to take several steps to ensure your rights are secure and build the best defense:
- Remain silent: You can remain silent under the Fifth Amendment. Politely but firmly tell the police, “I am exercising my right to remain silent, and I want to speak to an criminal defense attorney.” Do not answer questions, explain yourself, or offer statements, even if you think it might help. Anything you say can be used against you in court.
- Request an attorney immediately: Once you ask for a lawyer, police questioning must stop until your attorney is present. In Indiana, murder is a severe charge, and you’ll need an experienced Indiana criminal defense lawyer to help you.
- Cooperate physically, but not verbally: Follow basic instructions from law enforcement, like putting your hands up or getting into a vehicle to avoid additional charges like resisting arrest. However, do not volunteer information or consent to searches without your attorney’s advice. The less you say to the police without your criminal defense attorneys present, the better.
- Understand the charges: In Indiana, murder is defined as knowingly or intentionally killing another person or killing someone while committing certain dangerous felonies. Indiana does not have first or second-degree murder crimes. Still, penalties are severe if you acted intentionally: 45-65 years in prison, life without parole, or even the death penalty if aggravating circumstances are proven.
- Contact a seasoned criminal defense law firm: You must have the best lawyer to beat this serious charge. Our criminal defense attorneys have gotten murder charges dismissed or reduced before, so contact us immediately for a free legal consultation. We will outline your legal options after reviewing your case.
Building a Strong Defense Strategy
Working with skilled criminal defense attorneys to construct a robust defense is critical if you are charged with murder. Your criminal defense attorneys will meet with you to review the case, what happened, and the evidence against you.
Your criminal defense attorneys will create a defense strategy, but it depends on the case specifics and the prosecution’s evidence. The good news is that the prosecutor must prove their case beyond a reasonable doubt, and that is difficult.
Types of Criminal Defense Strategies
Your criminal defense lawyer may use one or several of the following murder defense strategies:
- Self-defense: Using reasonable force, the defendant acted to protect themselves from imminent harm or death. A typical example is during a robbery. The alleged suspect may try to rob you by brandishing a weapon, but you have the right to stand your ground in Indiana. You could pull your own weapon and kill the other party in self-defense if your life was in danger.
- Defense of others: The defendant used deadly force to protect another person from immediate danger, consistent with Indiana’s “Stand Your Ground” laws.
- Insanity: The defendant lacked the mental capacity to understand the nature or wrongfulness of their actions due to a severe mental disease or defect.
- Accidental killing: The death was unintentional, lacking the required intent for a murder conviction, potentially reducing it to manslaughter. This could reduce a potential sentence from decades in prison to a few years.
- Mistaken identity: The defendant was not the perpetrator, challenging the prosecution’s evidence linking them to the crime.
- Alibi: The defendant was elsewhere when the murder occurred, supported by credible evidence or witnesses.
- Lack of evidence: The prosecution fails to prove all elements of murder beyond a reasonable doubt, such as intent or causation.
- Provocation: The defendant acted in the heat of passion due to sufficient provocation, potentially reducing the charge to voluntary manslaughter.
- Intoxication: Voluntary or involuntary intoxication may negate the specific intent required for murder.
- Police misconduct: Evidence was obtained illegally, leading to the suppression of key prosecution evidence.
The Role of a Criminal Lawyer in Your Case
When facing a serious felony charge such as murder, it is essential to have a seasoned criminal defense lawyer advising you from the moment you are arrested or questioned. Your criminal defense lawyer can attend the police interrogation to safeguard your legal rights and prevent the police from engaging in misconduct.
Your attorney can investigate the murder charge against you and determine a sound defense strategy. They will review the evidence against you and consider if you were possibly overcharged. If so, your criminal law firm may negotiate with the prosecutor for a lesser charge, such as involuntary manslaughter. Or, your criminal defense attorney can take the case to trial and present it to the jury.
Last, your criminal law team can appeal your case if you are convicted. In some cases, police or prosecutorial misconduct led to an unfair trial.
Why Choose Our Indiana Criminal Defense Attorneys?
When facing a criminal charge or arrest, one of the initial steps you should take is to seek guidance from a seasoned defense attorney. Navigating the legal system can be both perplexing and deliberately daunting for defendants. Despite this, the law grants you critical rights that can be leveraged in crafting a sound defense.
Opting for representation from Gemma & Karimi, LLP can offer distinct advantages. Our firm’s attorneys, with their backgrounds as former prosecutors, bring a wealth of insight into judicial tendencies and prosecutorial tactics. This experience equips them to anticipate the prosecution’s approach, enabling them to construct a robust, multi-faceted defense tailored to counter the charges against you.
Gemma & Karimi, LLP adopts a proactive and goal-driven stance in their legal practice. They are committed to vigorously pursuing the desired results, ensuring that your defense is comprehensive and strategically sound.
Our team of dedicated criminal defense attorneys has more than 25 years of combined defense experience for serious felony charges. We have local criminal defense lawyers born and raised in Indianapolis, and you have 24/7 access to our Indiana criminal defense lawyer.
Our law firm has successfully defended more than 1,000 criminal cases, and we focus only on criminal defense. Gemma & Karimi offers free consultations to review your criminal law case and determine the best defense strategy.
Expungement Laws in Indiana
In the state of Indiana, expunging a murder conviction or charge is generally impossible under the state’s expungement laws. The law outlines the eligibility criteria for expungement, and certain serious offenses, including murder, are explicitly excluded from being expunged.
For convictions, Indiana law prohibits expungement of convictions for offenses classified as violent or sex offenses. Murder is in this category. Also, state law limits expungement for felonies that result in the death of another person. Even for less serious convictions, expungement is a one-time opportunity in a person’s lifetime, and strict waiting periods and conditions apply—but murder convictions remain categorically ineligible.
For charges that did not result in a conviction, expungement is possible. This applies to non-conviction records, such as arrests or charges that were dismissed, resulted in an acquittal, or were resolved through a diversion program. You must wait one year from the date of arrest, have no pending charges, and meet other conditions, such as no convictions in the previous year. Our criminal defense lawyer can answer questions about the possibility of expunging a charge or conviction.
Common Murder Charge Myths in Indiana
You may be frantically searching for information online about a murder charge in Indiana. Here are some common myths about these charges:
Myth 1: Indiana Has “First-Degree” and “Second-Degree” Murder Charges
Unlike many states that categorize murder into degrees (e.g., first-degree for premeditated killings and second-degree for intentional but unplanned killings), Indiana does not use this terminology. In Indiana, murder is a single felony charge defined under state law as knowingly or intentionally killing another person or killing someone while committing certain felonies. Other homicide offenses, like voluntary manslaughter or involuntary manslaughter, exist but are separate from the murder statute.
Myth 2: You Can Only Be Charged With Murder If You Directly Killed Someone
Indiana’s felony murder rule allows someone to be charged with murder even if they didn’t personally kill the victim. If a death occurs during the commission or attempted commission of specific felonies, such as robbery, all participants in the felony can be held liable for murder. For example, if two people rob a store and one of them kills the clerk, both can face murder charges, regardless of who pulled the trigger.
Myth 3: Self-Defense Automatically Clears You of a Murder Charge
While Indiana law recognizes a strong right to self-defense, including using deadly force with no duty to retreat in certain situations, it’s not an automatic get-out-of-jail-free card. The defense must be deemed reasonable by a judge or jury based on the circumstances. Prosecutors may still pursue charges, and it’s up to the defendant to prove their actions were justified, often requiring skilled legal representation.
Myth 4: Murder Always Leads to the Death Penalty
The death penalty is an option in Indiana, but it’s not automatic. For it to apply, prosecutors must prove at least one aggravating circumstance beyond a reasonable doubt, and those factors must outweigh any mitigating circumstances. Most murder convictions result in 45 to 65 years in prison or life without parole, not execution.
Myth 5: Intent Is Always Required for a Murder Charge
While intentional killing is one basis for a murder charge in Indiana, the felony murder rule doesn’t require intent to kill. If someone dies during the commission of a dangerous felony, the participants can be charged with murder even if the death was unintentional. This often surprises people who assume murder always involves premeditation or malice.
Myth 6: A Murder Charge Means You’re Guilty Until Proven Innocent
Like all crimes in the U.S., a murder charge in Indiana requires the prosecution to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The defendant is presumed innocent, and the burden is on the state to present sufficient evidence. Public perception might lean toward guilt due to the severity of the charge, but legally, the process remains the same as for any other crime.
Frequently Asked Questions
A murder charge is a serious matter, and you probably have questions. Common questions and answers include these:
In Indiana, the distinction between murder and voluntary manslaughter lies primarily in the mental state of the offender and the circumstances surrounding the killing. Murder is the intentional and unlawful killing of another human being, done knowingly or intentionally. Voluntary manslaughter is an intentional killing, but it occurs under a mitigating circumstance, such as ‘the heat of the moment.’
For example, suppose you found out that your spouse was having an affair. Then, you saw your spouse’s boyfriend on the street and ran them over with your car. The act was intentional but not premeditated, and may have been done in the heat of passion. This could lead to a voluntary manslaughter charge.
The first step to defending yourself against a murder charge is to say as little as possible to the police. They will use anything you say against you in court. You could easily say something that damages your criminal case. Next, always ask for an experienced criminal defense lawyer if you are questioned or arrested on a murder charge.
A good defense lawyer in Indianapolis should have many years of experience and proven results in felony criminal defense. Gemma & Karimi possess 25 years of combined criminal defense experience, and they are former prosecutors, so they know how the state thinks when trying to convict someone on a murder charge. Also, you should look for attorneys who have many criminal defense awards. Our attorneys were named to the Super Lawyers list in 2018, 2019, and 2020.
Indiana recognizes self-defense as a justification for homicide. A person is justified in using reasonable force, including deadly force, if they reasonably believe it’s necessary to protect themselves or a third party from imminent danger of serious bodily injury or death. The key is that the force you used must be proportionate to the threat faced.
Also, Indiana is a “stand your ground” state. This means that if someone is lawfully present in a location and not engaged in illegal activity, they have no obligation to retreat before using force in self-defense. If you claim self-defense, you must provide strong evidence to support your case, such as eyewitness testimony or physical evidence.
Yes. A murder charge can be reduced to a lesser offense, such as voluntary manslaughter, involuntary manslaughter, or reckless homicide, through plea negotiations or based on the evidence presented. For example, mitigating circumstances, such as a witness testifying that you acted in self-defense, may come to light during the trial.
A charge dismissal could occur for various reasons, such as if there is insufficient evidence to convict you or if there was a violation of your rights during the arrest. Your Indianapolis defense attorney will always look for evidence and circumstances that could lead to a charge reduction or dismissal.
In Indiana, the distinction between first-degree and second-degree murder doesn’t exist under those exact terms because the state uses a different classification system. Instead, Indiana law defines “murder” and distinguishes it from other homicide offenses like “voluntary manslaughter” or “involuntary manslaughter” based on intent and circumstances. First-degree murder does not exist under state law, but murder that is done intentionally and with forethought will be punished the most severely.
The equivalent of second-degree murder in Indiana may be voluntary manslaughter. This is where you intentionally caused someone’s death, but it was done in a moment of heat or passion.
Proving intent is critical to an Indiana murder charge because an intentional killing is what makes the act a murder. On the other hand, if the killing was accidental, the charge may be involuntary manslaughter, which has less severe punishments.
Say as little as you can to the police and ask for a criminal defense law firm to represent you. Always ask for criminal defense attorneys if you are arrested or brought into the police station for questioning.
An experienced Indianapolis murder defense lawyer can help your case in many ways. First, they understand Indiana law and the differences between murder and manslaughter, which involve intent. They also understand the complexities of various defenses, including self-defense, and know how to raise reasonable doubt to beat a serious charge.
Criminal defense attorneys are also skilled in negotiating with prosecutors and can beat the prosecutor’s case if the matter goes to trial.
Yes, a murder conviction can be appealed in Indiana. After a conviction, you can file an appeal with the Indiana Court of Appeals. This process typically begins with filing a Notice of Appeal within 30 days of the sentencing. The appeal allows the defendant to challenge the conviction or sentence based on legal errors that may have occurred during the trial, such as inappropriate admission of evidence, incorrect jury instructions, or violations of your legal rights.
In Indiana, most defendants get a bond set by a judge, but murder cases are an exception. Bail is often denied or set extremely high due to the severity of the charge, though it’s up to the judge’s discretion after a hearing.
Do not discuss your case with anyone except a qualified criminal defense attorney. Remain silent if police question, as anything you say can be used against you. Contact an experienced Indiana defense lawyer immediately to evaluate your case and build a defense strategy.
If you didn’t intend to kill but your actions caused a death, you might face a lesser charge like involuntary manslaughter or reckless homicide instead of murder. However, intent can sometimes be inferred from your actions, so prosecutors may still pursue a murder charge depending on the circumstances.
The timeline varies widely depending on the case’s complexity, evidence, and court schedules. It could take months to years, especially if it goes to trial. Pretrial motions, plea negotiations, and appeals can extend the process.
Indiana Murder Statistics
More people are facing murder charges in Indiana as the state continues to wrestle with population growth combined with economic stagnation and rising crime. Murder statistics in Indiana reveal a complex picture of crime trends across the state, with notable variations between urban and rural areas. In recent years, Indianapolis, the state’s capital and largest city, has consistently recorded some of the highest homicide numbers in Indiana.
Homicide Crimes Rising In Indianapolis
For instance, in 2024, Indianapolis reported 209 homicides, a slight decrease from the 219 recorded in 2023, yet still marking the fifth consecutive year the city surpassed 200 homicides. This figure reflects a persistent challenge with violent crime despite a reported 11% drop in criminal homicides from 2023 to 2024, according to the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department.
Indiana Murder Rate Higher Than US Overall
Statewide, Indiana’s murder rate has historically outpaced the national average, with a 2020 spike showing a 30% increase in homicides, mainly driven by gun violence. This trend highlights broader societal issues such as poverty, lack of education, and economic disparity, which officials often cite as contributing factors.
100th Homicide Posted In Indianapolis by Mid-2024
Focusing on Indianapolis, the city’s homicide statistics show progress and ongoing struggles. By mid-2024, the city had reached its 100th homicide before July, signaling a pace that, while slower than the peak of 272 homicides in 2021, still indicates significant violence. Efforts to curb this trend have included increased investment in policing technology, such as license plate readers and public safety cameras, contributing to a 72% homicide clearance rate in 2024.
More Arrests Noted For Indianapolis Murders
Community cooperation has also played a key role, with 31 arrests out of 78 criminal homicides reported by June 24, 2024. However, challenges persist, particularly with youth violence, as non-fatal shootings among juveniles rose by 7% in 2024, even as overall gun deaths among teens decreased. These statistics highlight a mixed outcome: while some violent crime metrics are improving, specific demographics and neighborhoods continue to bear the brunt of the violence.
Other Indiana Cities Grapple With Murder Cases
Beyond Indianapolis, other Indiana cities like Gary, South Bend, and Evansville also rank among the state’s deadliest, each grappling with elevated murder rates compared to state and national averages. Gary, once a bustling steel town, has seen its murder rate soar alongside economic decline, while South Bend’s violent crime rate stands at over five times the state average.
Evansville, in southwest Indiana, similarly reports higher-than-average homicide figures. Statewide, Indiana’s murder rate reached 23.7 per 100,000 people in some analyses, placing it among the higher rates in the U.S. Collectively, Indiana’s murder statistics paint a picture of a state wrestling with deep-rooted issues, where persistent hotspots of violence temper progress in reducing homicides. Anyone charged with murder in Indiana should always retain a skilled criminal lawyer immediately for the best case outcome.
Contact a Murder Criminal Lawyer In Indiana
Have you been charged with murder in Indiana? Your future is at risk and you need a skilled criminal lawyer to defend your rights immediately.
Our experienced Indianapolis criminal lawyer will get to work on your case today to provide the most vigorous defense to this serious charge. Our skilled criminal law attorneys have an impressive record of felony charge reductions and case dismissals and look forward to defending your rights. Contact us today at (317) 602-5970 for a confidential legal consultation. We provide excellent legal representation to all our clients in the State of Indiana.
Contact Our Firm
Cras dapibus. Vivamus quis mi. In consectetuer turpis ut velit. Praesent blandit laoreet nibh. Nullam nulla eros, ultricies sit amet, nonummy id, imperdiet feugiat, pede.
